UK agrees to time-bound talks on slavery’s historical harms, but rules out reparations
Commonwealth leaders say Britain has agreed to structured, time-bound talks on the historical harms of the transatlantic slave trade, while Prime Minister Andy Burnham has ruled out financial reparations.
Britain has agreed to take part in structured, time-bound talks addressing the historical harms of the transatlantic slave trade, Commonwealth leaders have said, in a communique issued at the end of the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Antigua and Barbuda.
The leaders welcomed what they described as the agreement of the government of the United Kingdom to engage in a structured, time-bound, inclusive and good-faith dialogue with affected parties, addressing the transatlantic trafficking of enslaved Africans and its historical harms.
The wording, reported by the BBC and Sky News, marks a further step in a debate that has run for years inside the Commonwealth, where Caribbean governments and reparations campaigners have pressed Britain to confront its role in slavery and its lasting consequences.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who attended the summit in St John’s alongside the King, had already opened the door to a formal apology on behalf of the United Kingdom for its role in the slave trade. He has, however, ruled out the prospect of direct financial reparations.
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has indicated that the dialogue is likely to conclude within about a year, although officials said the precise timeframe would be agreed at a later date. Asked whether a formal apology could be reached by the time Britain hosts the G20 leaders’ summit in Manchester next November, Miliband told BBC Newscast that, broadly speaking, yes.
The communique said the time had come for a meaningful, truthful and respectful conversation towards forging a common future based on equity. It does not, by itself, commit Britain to paying compensation, and British ministers have instead pointed to other forms of cooperation, including proposals on debt and targeted investment.
Reporting on the outcome also pointed to non-cash measures under discussion, including a proposed debt-reset approach involving non-G7 lenders and the private sector, and £40 million from existing budgets over three years for Caribbean infrastructure and green energy projects, with British taxpayers not asked to pay extra.
The development follows an earlier position set out before the summit, when the Caribbean Community welcomed Burnham’s openness to an apology but insisted that reparations must stay on the table, arguing that a dialogue which excluded them from the start could not be complete.
A YouGov poll cited in coverage of the talks found that 52 per cent of Britons backed an apology, while 65 per cent opposed reparations, a split that helps explain why ministers have drawn a line between acknowledging the past and paying compensation for it.
What happens next will depend on how the dialogue is structured, who sits at the table, and whether it produces a formal apology, practical remedies, or both. For now, the communique gives the process a name, a framework and an expected timescale, but leaves the hardest questions — what an apology would say, and what, if anything, follows it — still to be negotiated.
More in UK
Photo: The interior of the UK Supreme Court in London (file image)
UKPalestine Action ban challenged at UK Supreme Court as protesters arrested outside
The co-founder of Palestine Action has asked the UK Supreme Court to overturn the group’s proscription as a terrorist organisation, arguing the ban is disproportionate, as police arrested more than two dozen demonstrators outside the court.
Photo: Half Moon Bay in Antigua and Barbuda, host of the Commonwealth summit
UKCaricom welcomes UK openness to slavery apology but insists reparations must stay on the table
The Caribbean Community has welcomed British Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s openness to a formal apology for slavery, but has rejected his ruling-out of financial reparations, saying a dialogue that excludes reparations from the start cannot be complete.
Photo: The new US Embassy building in Nine Elms, London
UKLondon police arrest 139 outside US Embassy at Palestine Action protest days before Supreme Court appeal
London police arrested 139 people outside the US Embassy on Saturday after a protest in support of the banned group Palestine Action, days before the Supreme Court hears an appeal against the ban.