UK doubles the wait for permanent settlement to ten years, but spares most care workers after a Labour revolt
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has unveiled a sweeping overhaul of settlement rules, doubling the standard wait to ten years while allowing most care workers already in Britain to keep the five-year route.
Britain is to double the standard wait for permanent settlement from five years to ten, under a sweeping overhaul unveiled on Monday by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood — but most care workers already in the country will be spared the longest delays after weeks of pressure from Labour MPs and cabinet colleagues.
The announcement, reported by Reuters and detailed in The Times and The Sun, reshapes what ministers call “earned settlement”: the right to live in Britain permanently will no longer follow automatically from time spent in the country, but will depend on earnings, conduct and contribution. Mahmood told MPs that “those who contribute most will settle fastest” and that “those who don’t play by the rules will be refused or wait longer”.
Under the original plan, published in 2025, lower-skilled workers faced a wait of up to fifteen years. That maximum has now been cut to ten years for most migrants on work, talent and family visas, a climbdown that followed warnings from within Labour that the tougher version was, in the words of some MPs, “un-British”. Government sources nevertheless insisted the reforms remained a “total transformation” of the system, with about 500,000 applications still facing delay.
The largest concession covers care workers, the group at the centre of the revolt. Around 300,000 care workers and their dependants — roughly three-quarters of those affected — who arrived in Britain before May 2025 and earn at least £25,000 a year will still be able to apply for indefinite leave to remain after five years. About 100,000 others who do not meet those conditions will have to wait longer, though many will be offered a further five-year visa to give them a second chance at qualifying.
The concession also extends in part to nursing auxiliaries and teaching assistants who arrived before May 2025, and the government has dropped a proposed ban on newly settled migrants claiming benefits, as well as a plan to make adult dependants qualify independently of their partners. Couples will generally be allowed to settle together, provided they meet the residence and other conditions.
Faster routes remain for higher earners and some public-sector workers. Those earning at least £50,271 a year, and many skilled public-sector staff, will still be able to qualify after five years, while those earning more than £125,000 will be able to settle in three years, according to Reuters. By contrast, refugees who arrived by small boat face the harshest treatment: a wait of twenty years, rising to thirty if they do not enter work or study.
Every applicant will also face stricter tests. Mahmood told MPs that anyone seeking settled status must have a clean criminal record, speak English to A-level standard, owe no tax debt and be up to date with national insurance contributions. The changes are due to take effect in 2027 and will apply retrospectively to workers already in Britain, meaning people who arrived expecting a five-year route will find the rules changed beneath them.
The political backdrop is the surge in migration that followed Brexit, often called the “Boriswave”. More than 616,000 visas were issued through the wider Health and Care route between 2022 and 2024, including dependants, and the Home Office has estimated that up to 1.6 million people could become eligible for settlement between 2026 and 2030. Mahmood has previously warned that settling low-paid care workers could cost taxpayers around £10 billion over their lifetimes — a figure the Conservatives seized on, claiming the concessions themselves could cost up to £10 billion.
Reaction split sharply along party lines. Labour MPs who had pressed for the climbdown welcomed protection for workers they said had “answered our call when we needed them” during post-pandemic staffing shortages, while Reform UK accused Mahmood of “betraying Britain” and promised to abolish indefinite leave to remain altogether. Care-sector employers, who have warned for months that longer waits would worsen chronic staff shortages, are expected to welcome the exemption, even as they note that tens of thousands of workers still fall outside it.
What happens next is parliamentary rather than immediate: the final rules are expected to be formally laid before Parliament ahead of taking effect in 2027, and the transitional arrangements for people already on the path to settlement will be closely scrutinised. For the hundreds of thousands of migrants whose plans now hinge on earnings thresholds, arrival dates and English tests, Monday’s statement has replaced one uncertainty with another — a longer, harder road to permanence for most, and a preserved five-year route for the care workers Britain decided it could not afford to lose.
More in News
NewsNorth Korea test-fires strategic cruise missiles tipped with a dispersal warhead, state media reports
NewsUK rejects Iran's 'terrorist' label for Royal Navy and RAF as Tehran designates MI6 a hostile group
News